As much as we want to pick a favorite e-commerce platform, like most things, it depends.

As much as we want to pick a favorite e-commerce platform, like most things, it depends.

Whether you’re just getting started or looking to improve performance and increase your online presence, choosing an e-commerce platform is one of the most important decisions to make for your business.

Why?

It is the beating heart of your business and what users interact with everyday. It should be easy to use, quick to navigate, and offer expansion options for when you’re ready to upgrade.

So, who wins the best e-commerce platform? The TL;DR is: It depends. Shopify wins for ease of use, while WordPress wins for flexibility.

Siege has utilized WordPress for nearly a decade on our own website and client sites, building out interactive assets and blog redesigns to improve conversions and performance.

However, making a decision on your content management system (CMS) is no one-size-fits-all approach — it’s more complicated than that.

With that being said, it’s important to understand the pros and cons of each platform to understand which one is best for your business.

Read on to understand how we came to our conclusion.

What is WordPress?

WordPress just turned 19 years old, which means it’s some of the oldest technology on the modern internet. While its roots may run deep, the open source team behind the software keeps pushing forward to make it the best CMS for individuals and businesses of all types.

According to W3Techs, WordPress powers 43% of all sites on the internet.

Pros and Cons of WordPress

Pros

  • Easily launch a new site with lots of features on a budget
  • Lots of available resources to help with any issues
  • Drag-and-drop website builder
  • A multitude of options for additional features

Cons

  • Frequent manual updates and maintenance can be bothersome
  • Optimizing for best performance can be tricky
  • Added functionality can cost significantly more than the base system
  • Plugins required for e-commerce functionality

Pros and cons of WordPress

What is Shopify?

Shopify is also pretty old, having been launched in 2006. It is a dedicated e-commerce platform with everything a modern business needs to start selling online quickly. With one quick signup, you can:

  • Buy a domain name
  • Configure your website
  • Add products to sell

There’s no hosting decision, no complicated procedures to synchronize your domain to your website, and virtually no technical hurdles to jump.

1.75 million merchants sell using the Shopify platform.

Pros and Cons of Shopify

Pros

  • Fully managed platform frees you to run your business
  • Built-in payment system
  • Inventory management
  • Built-in marketing tools, such as follow-up and abandoned cart emails

Cons

  • Apps can add significant monthly cost
  • Limited blogging capabilities
  • Harder to migrate away once established
  • Limited theme and add-on app selection

Pros and cons of Shopify

How To Choose an E-Commerce Platform

Before choosing the best e-commerce platform for you, it’s necessary to ask yourself the following questions:

  • What is your budget?
  • What should the website look like?
  • Do you need to add functionality with plugins or apps?
  • What is your technical expertise?
  • Will you require customer support?
  • How much customization do you want?

Budget

For small businesses, this is likely the most important consideration, while larger businesses may only care about performance and customization opportunities.

For both options, you’ll need to factor in the cost of your domain name, developers, and marketing.

WordPress

WordPress is technically a free and open-source software, which makes it more budget-friendly. However, it’s always going to cost some money to create a site.

Budget hosting is fine for an information site just starting out, but businesses with serious aspirations should look to higher tiers for best performance. Why? In the e-commerce world, performance equals sales.

  • WordPress standard hosting cost = $3 – $15
  • WordPress managed hosting cost = $25 – $500
  • E-commerce plugins subject to additional costs

Yes, in general, managed hosting is more expensive, but what you get in return has a tangible benefit: the software is optimized for their servers and usually includes a list of helpful features, like backup/restore functions and global content delivery networks.

Shopify

On Shopify there’s no difference between their lowest and highest priced tiers in terms of performance. All sites run on the same highly optimized global network.

The main differences are in the transaction fees you’ll pay and the higher shipping discounts in the upper tiers.

  • Apps can add significant monthly cost
  • Expert developers may cost more than WordPress developers

Winner

This was a close call, but in the end, WordPress wins this category due to freedom of choice — an optimal choice for e-commerce platforms:

  • Choice of hosting to fit your budget and specs
  • Choice of payment processor
  • Choice of shipping provider

WordPress beats Shopify in the Budget category

Themes

While the performance and content of your website are key factors to your site’s success, the layout and design is the first impression.

Themes are files that form the look and feel of your website and ultimately influences the likelihood of the user staying on your site.

WordPress

Plain and simple: There are a multitude of free and commercial themes available for WordPress, which makes it a great resource in this category.

At the time of publication, WordPress has over 9,800 free themes available. You can find themes that target nearly any industry, as well as general purpose themes that you can customize to your heart’s content.

It’s not an exaggeration to state that availability of themes is one of the biggest reasons why WordPress is so popular.

Speaking of customization, most themes allow at least some customization, whether selecting different fonts, colors, or layouts. For WordPress, all of that comes in an easy to use dashboard.

Shopify

Shopify has a much smaller catalog of free and commercial themes.

Although Shopify themes don’t offer as much customization as WordPress, it won’t be difficult to select a base theme and make it unique to your brand.

However, there are many businesses that exist to help you customize your theme or develop one from the ground up. This is a disadvantage, since it requires a developer to create a theme to match your brand. Plus, it adds cost to get your business running.

Ultimately, the quality of the existing themes is just as good as WordPress and will likely suit your needs as you get established if you decide to go this route.

Winner

In the end, WordPress takes the cake in this category due to the sheer volume of choice.

WordPress beats Shopify in the Themes category

Plugins and Apps

Plugins are a necessity in website development and extend the functionality of the core system beyond its initial purpose.

For WordPress and Shopify, plugins make it easy to add advanced features to set your business apart or improve the experience your customers have when visiting your site.

WordPress Plugins

When WordPress launched their plugin system in 2004, it was the start of a new era for the CMS. Some of the first commercial plugins for WordPress were for e-commerce sites, so this is a long-established and respected category for them.

In WordPress, plugins can supplement ‘normal’ website functionality with things like:

The most popular e-commerce plugins for WordPress include:

From a technical perspective, plugins run within WordPress itself.

Advantages of the WordPress plugin system:

  • Tight integration with the core system

Disadvantages of the WordPress plugin system:

  • Poorly coded plugins can crash the whole site
  • Historically, the cause of most WordPress site problems

Shopify Apps

Shopify has apps that are like WordPress plugins, as they extend the functionality of your site.

Some examples of apps for Shopify are:

  • Recommendation and review systems
  • Subscription orders
  • Social media feeds

Apps typically run outside the Shopify platform. Just like WordPress plugins, they can tap into pages and users, but also products and orders.

However, unlike WordPress plugins, they don’t run within the platform.

Advantages of this approach:

  • Clear separation of the core system and apps
  • Won’t crash the site if faulty

Disadvantages of Shopify apps:

  • Difficult for developers

Many apps charge high monthly fees, whereas the typical WordPress plugin is a one-time purchase.

Winner

WordPress wins again for volume and diversity of choice. If you want to easily add functionality to your site, there is most likely a plugin to suit your needs.

WordPress beats Shopify in the Plugins category

Technical Matters

Do you have the inclination to manage your website? If you’re the curious type and want to learn more about running your own site, this is a good way to get started.

WordPress

If managing your website is ideal, WordPress may be a good choice for you. You’ll get experience installing and updating plugins, configuring the theme, and optimizing the site for performance.

Shopify

If you’d rather just manage your business and sales, Shopify is the better option.

Once you configure your theme, you’re all set to start promotion and start selling your products. All the technical considerations are handled by the experts at Shopify.

Winner

Shopify wins this category because they manage all aspects of the platform, from the software to the network — easy peasy.

If you’d rather leave the details to the experts, contact us to help with your website today.

Shopify beats WordPress in the Technical Matters category

Support

Running an online business can be technically challenging, so there may come a time when you need help.

WordPress

The open-source nature of WordPress means you generally have to rely on information from your developer or online sources.

If you do this yourself, this takes away time from running your business. Otherwise, you’ll have to hire someone to make changes.

Shopify

Shopify support is available 24/7 to help with any problems in your store.

This might be something as simple as adjusting an option in your theme or more challenging issues such as inventory management. Your monthly fee helps cover any problem you may have.

Winner

Shopify triumphs again with on-call support staff. With one call or chat, you can resolve most problems quickly. Forget the endless searches and trial and error changes and get straight to the solution.

Shopify beats WordPress in the Support category

Customization

You want your website to mesh with the rest of your brand identity, right?

Customization refers to the process of adjusting options for your website to make it yours.

WordPress

While both platforms allow customization, WordPress is the clear winner here.

Not only does the system encourage plugins to alter functionality, there are tons of global developers ready to take on your project. The WordPress ecosystem is so large as to dwarf the economies of small countries.

Shopify

The options for customization on Shopify are a bit more limited.

It kind of makes sense since a lot of functionality is built into the core platform. That said, customizing your store’s theme is a great way to stand out and is an easy task for developers and non-developers alike.

Winner

If it wasn’t clear yet that WordPress equals choice, here we have another example.

It’s important to note that the best way to get exactly what you want is to hire an agency with the resources to make a great looking website, and also have it perform its best. We’re here to help when you’re ready.

WordPress beats Shopify in the Customization category

Don’t Forget: Site and Data Security

It’s a no-brainer that customer data should be secure, right? Additionally, you don’t want to be a victim of hackers exploiting your site to serve malware.

That’s where the security consideration comes into play.

WordPress

Even though WordPress is notorious for security breaches, did you know that most of these problems are in plugins?

The core system, while resilient against attacks, is not very useful without plugins to enable e-commerce functionality.

Once you add an e-commerce plugin and start accepting payments, you open your site up to potential bad actors. Then, you have to add plugins for security, spam protection, and logging. All those plugins add up in potential cost increases and performance decreases.

There are several well-respected security plugins to help protect your site against hackers. Our favorites:

Shopify

Shopify has you covered with secure payment processing. They also work hard to ensure that hackers cannot access your customer’s personal data.

Winner

Shopify prevails again in this department. While WordPress gives you choice, this is one area where lack of choice is a good thing — Shopify just does it right.

Shopify beats WordPress in the Security category

Other Platforms to Consider

There are several alternatives to each platform, depending on your needs.

For example, if you have experienced developers that are more productive with other platforms, then selecting one of these platforms may not make sense for you.

Additionally, if you have hundreds of thousands — or even millions — of pieces of content, these platforms may not offer acceptable performance.

Competing with WordPress for pure CMS market share is Drupal and Joomla, though each has seen their user numbers decline in recent years.

Many lesser-known platforms are in the process of dying off, while others compete to take market share from the leader — WordPress.

You may have already heard of Squarespace, but did you know that they aren’t the only all-in-one solution? There’s also Webflow, Wix, and Weebly, which all include e-commerce, blogging, and information site features.

Other possible reasons to consider other platforms:

  • Enhanced security requirements – Drupal
  • More options for user permissions – Joomla
  • Complex content types and relationships – Drupal and Joomla
  • Simple site publishing – Weebly and Wix

Our Winner: WordPress

WordPress beats Shopify in this comparison

For ultimate flexibility, WordPress is the clear choice.

If you already use WordPress for your website, consider adding an e-commerce plugin to scale your business significantly .

If you’re just starting out, choosing an all-in-one platform like Shopify can get you selling in no time. Start with their free trial to gauge its workflow and whether the available themes fit your brand.

Whichever platform you choose, we can help design, develop, and optimize your online presence.

Fresh out of the oven.

Secret recipes sold here.